"ALL CAPS IN DEFENSE OF LIBERTY IS NO VICE."

Sunday, March 29, 2009

CONGRESS ACTED UNCONSTITUTIONALLY?

So opines George F. Will in today's Washington Post:
It is high time Americans heard an argument that might turn a vague national uneasiness into a vivid awareness of something going very wrong. The argument is that the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 (EESA) is unconstitutional.
By enacting it, Congress did not in any meaningful sense make a law. Rather, it made executive branch officials into legislators. Congress said to the executive branch, in effect: "Here is $700 billion. You say you will use some of it to buy up banks' 'troubled assets.' But if you prefer to do anything else with the money -- even, say, subsidize automobile companies -- well, whatever."

[...]

The Supreme Court has said: "That Congress cannot delegate legislative power to the president is a principle universally recognized as vital to the integrity and maintenance of the system of government ordained by the Constitution." And the court has said that properly delegated discretion must come with "an intelligible principle" and must "clearly delineate" a policy that limits the discretion. EESA flunks that test.

With EESA, Congress forces the country to ponder the paradox of sovereignty: If sovereign people freely choose to surrender their sovereignty, is this willed subordination really subordination?

It is. Congress has done that. A court should hear the argument that Congress cannot so divest itself of powers vested in it.
Pity that too many Americans won't listen or care, even as our Constitution is being dismantled right before our very eyes.

2 comments:

Layer Seven said...

Excellent point (Reli and George). The Constitution was suspended by Dims decades ago, however; and Republicans are accommodating.

For example, the Republic no longer the provides borders which it guaranteed to the states.

And ad nauseum, ad infinitum.

Reliapundit said...

GREAT POST - AOW! (NOT RELI!)