"ALL CAPS IN DEFENSE OF LIBERTY IS NO VICE."

Sunday, April 29, 2007

NEWSWEEK MAKES YET ANOTHER STAB AT LIBERAL CREDIBILITY, REGURGITATES MUSLIM BROTHERHOOD REFORM MEME

This is how overeager faux sophistication filters downward through self-consciously bourgie cocktail parties, until it hardens into conventional wisdom. Allahpundit calls it "disgraceful from beginning to end", which are strong words coming from the center-right's most measured blogger.

This began with that absurd Foreign Affairs article that tried to outweigh the MB's overwhelming and fundamental commitment to sharia with half-uttered suggestions that maybe some time in the future the MB might be less genocidal (also: they love kids!) The fact that it's appearing in a popular news magazine instead of an elite foreign policy journal doesn't make the argument any less stupid. Or any less execrable.

Bonus question: Is the reapproachment between the MB and the American realist-Democratic camp being driven by media coverage of MB reform? Or are partisans in think tanks and newsrooms making excuses for policies that are being informally floated by realists and Democrats?

[Cross-posted to Mere Rhetoric]

No comments: